a friend and i were talking about this today. we have both recently moved to indianapolis and we're still figuring out our new lives in this new city. finding a church was pretty easy for me, but she's still on the search. i asked her what she was looking for and automatically she started talking about the worship music style. actually, most of our conversation centered around church music.
as a daughter of not one but two music teachers and church musicians, i fully appreciate the impact music has on one's worship experience. it can truly make or break the communion with God. and that's just it, the purpose of worship is to commune with our Maker, right? i have no problem listing worship music as one of the top factors when finding a new church. my frustration lies with people who list it is the only factor.
actually, no. my frustration lies with the church. because we are the ones who have fueled this obsession with worship music style. how many churches have divided over worship styles? too many to count. i hear it all the time from family members who attend a small town church with one traditional service and one contemporary service. they claim that the contemporary service congregation doesn't participate in any other aspect of church life. "it's like they're a completely separate church." well, i bet if i talked to people in the contemporary service congregation they'd say the same thing.
how did it get this way? when did we decide that worship services were the most important part of the church? when did we decide that people who don't attend the same church or even the same worship service as us were somehow strange or wrong?
let me tell you about my new church because i think it's nearly everything i have hoped for, for many years now. i'm not going to say it's perfect (because what ever is?) but it is a really great start. various friends and colleagues told me to check out this church when they heard i was moving to indianapolis. some recommended it because it is so big. others recommended it simply because of the faith tradition. neither is the reason i stay.
i stay because the church values both individual and community experiences with the Sustainer. i stay because the pastors mirror the diversity found in the congregation. i stay because the congregation is the first truly open congregation i have ever been a part of. i stay because there is a real respect for the vibrancy of the arts. i stay because there are a variety of classes on a variety of topics in a variety of learning styles at a variety of times with a variety of expected commitment levels. i stay because there is a deeply rooted call to congregational action with the community - both local and worldwide. i stay because the church understands that it must be relevant and it strives to be so. i stay because they are more worried about the message they teach and the people they are than the clothes they wear or the technology they use. i stay because they have a heart for justice in every sense of the word.
my favorite worship music style is the kind i just haven't found in a church yet. i'd rather sit on a rocking chair on my porch singing along to a blind willie johnson record than dance around to the latest david crowder band craziness any day. don't get me wrong, i like david crowder band. there's a time and a place for great songs like "you are my joy" or "shine" and who doesn't love a little church hoedown with "i saw the light", but those simply don't stir my soul like shane and shane's "yearn" or rev. dorsey's "precious lord". and few songs can break my heart and make me weep like blind willie johnson's "dark was the night, cold was the ground", a lyric-less reflection on the crucifixion of Christ, because why put words to feelings that leave you speechless...
worship music is important. worship itself is vital. but it's not everything. when looking for a church, i always refer back to john wesley's quadrilateral. does this church recognize various interpretations of scripture? does this church have a rich sense of tradition? does this church value personal life experience? does this church use sound reason with wisdom? i find that if i can answer a strong, honest "yes" to each of those questions then i've probably found a church worth investing myself into, a place where I can meet my Savior, a congregation with whom I can explore and study my faith in challenging and exciting ways, a community where i can stretch and grow and yes, even worship, regardless of the music style.
















